Guide
Why people aren't signing up, and how to tell
Low signups have a short list of causes, and each one leaves a different trace. Split the journey into stages, find the stage where people drop, and you know which fix to make. Here is how to read each stage, and how to watch simulated visitors try your signup before more traffic hits it.
Why are people not signing up?
Find the stage first. If visitors never click the signup button, the page has not convinced them: the offer is unclear, unbelievable or not for them. If they click but do not finish, the form asks too much, fails, or surprises them with a card or a phone number. If they sign up but never verify or come back, the problem is the email or the first screen after signup. Your analytics show the stage; asking people shows the reason.
Three different problems wearing one number
A low signup rate can mean the page does not persuade, the form loses people, or the account never gets used. Teams often fix the one they find most interesting, usually the page design, while the real leak is a broken verification email or a required phone field. Finding the stage takes an afternoon and saves weeks of the wrong fix.
- Split the journey into stages and find where the drop is.
- The usual causes at each stage, and how to check each one.
- What analytics, recordings and surveys can and cannot tell you.
- How to send simulated visitors through your signup before real newcomers do.
How it works
- 01
Map the stages
Visit, click the signup button, start the form, submit it, verify the email, reach the first useful screen. Make sure each stage records an event in your analytics.
- 02
Find the biggest drop
Build a funnel from those events and look for the stage that loses the most people, split by traffic source and device.
- 03
Check that stage by hand
Go through it yourself in a private window, on a phone, with a new email address, and note every surprise.
- 04
Find out why
Add a one-question survey at that stage, watch recordings of people who dropped there, or send simulated visitors through the signup and read where they left.
- 05
Fix one thing and recheck
Fix the most common cause at that stage, then check the same stage again before you look anywhere else.
Stage one: they never click sign up
If most visitors leave without clicking the button, the page has not made its case. The usual causes are a main heading that does not say what the product is, nothing that makes the claim believable, a missing price, or a button that does not say what happens next.
Check it with outside eyes on the page. In a Mimiq run that starts on the page, simulated visitors from your audience try to sign up, and the report ranks what stopped them before they reached the form. If the reasons are about trust or price, a new signup form will not help.
Stage two: they start but do not finish
Form drop off has concrete causes: too many fields, a field people do not want to fill in, such as a phone number or a company size with no reason given, password rules revealed only after a failure, an error message that does not say what is wrong, or a card request the page did not mention.
Login options matter too. A form that offers only one login provider loses people who do not use it, and a form that offers many can leave returning people unsure which one they used.
Check it by filling in the form badly on purpose: a wrong email format, a weak password, an empty field. Every error should say exactly how to fix it.
Stage three: they sign up but never verify or return
If accounts are created but not verified, look at the email. Sign up from a new address at a few different providers and check how long the verification email takes, whether it lands in spam, and whether it says clearly what to click.
If people sign up and verify but never come back, the problem is the first screen after signup. An empty dashboard with no clear first step loses people who just told you they were interested.
Watching strangers try it
Analytics shows the stage, recordings show what people did, and a short survey on the signup page gives a few real reasons. To see the whole journey through a newcomer's eyes before more traffic arrives, let simulated visitors try it. In a Mimiq run, each one opens your site in its own real browser and tries a task such as 'Sign up and start using it'.
They fill in your form with made up details and an email address of their own with a working inbox, so the verification step is part of the test. The report shows how far each one got, what broke, the step where each one left, and why, in its own words.
Every visitor in a Mimiq report is simulated. They find what breaks and what confuses. They do not predict how many real people will convert. A run shows where visitors like yours can get stuck. They cannot use Google or other social sign in providers, and a CAPTCHA can stop them. With paid credits, they can sign in with a test account you supply and open a protected preview. Any visitor stopped by one is marked as blocked by the site, and if it stops every visitor, the run fails and nothing is charged. A staging or preview address without bot protection works, as long as it is public or you give access.
Things that look like signup problems but are not
Traffic that was never going to sign up. A spike from a viral post or a broad campaign lowers the rate without anything being broken. Split by source before you change anything.
Broken tracking. If the signup event fires only on some paths, or stopped firing after a redesign, the rate looks low while signups are fine. Compare your analytics with the accounts in your database.
A deliberate trade. Asking for a card up front usually means fewer signups and more committed ones. If that was the choice, judge it by paid accounts, not by signups.
Where people drop, and why
| Stage | What you see | Common causes | How to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Page to button | Visits, few clicks on sign up | Unclear offer, no proof, hidden price, a button that does nothing | Outside eyes on the page, real people or simulated visitors |
| Button to form start | Clicks, few form starts | A surprise on the signup page: a card, a long form, a single login option | Open the signup page cold in a private window |
| Form start to submit | Starts, few submits | Too many fields, unexplained fields, unhelpful errors, password rules | Fill it in badly on purpose; watch recordings |
| Submit to verified | Accounts, few verified | A slow or spam filtered email, an unclear link | Sign up with new addresses at several providers |
| Verified to first use | Verified accounts, nobody returns | An empty first screen, no clear first step | Try the first minutes as a new user |
What you get with Mimiq
- 01
Run it by hand, or on every pull request
Paste a link and a task in the app and watch the visitors work. Or run them on every preview deploy: the GitHub Action comments on the pull request, any other CI can call the MCP endpoint, and your coding agent can run it too.
- 02
Bugs and usability problems in one report
The browser records errors and failed or slow requests on the step they happened. The visitors say where the wording or the steps confused them, and where they left.
- 03
Visitors that behave like your audience
Each visitor is a different profile with a reason to be there, matched to who the page is for, described by you, or built from your own customers.
- 04
A prompt to fix each problem
Every problem comes with a fix to paste into Cursor, Claude Code, Lovable or any coding agent, and one prompt hands over the top problems at once. Then send the same visitors through again.
- 05
Follow every visitor
See each visitor's whole path, step by step with screenshots, and what it was thinking at every step. Ask any visitor a question.
The browser records relevant JavaScript errors and failed or slow app requests encountered during the run, attached to the step where they occurred. The visitors are simulated: they find problems, they do not predict how many real people will convert.
Questions
What is a good signup rate?
It varies too much by product, price and traffic source for a standard figure to help. Compare your own rate by source and over time, and look at the stage by stage funnel rather than one overall number.
Should I remove the credit card requirement?
It usually trades more signups for fewer committed ones. Decide by what you care about further down, such as paid accounts, and if you test it, measure that rather than signups alone.
How do I know if my verification email is the problem?
Compare accounts created with accounts verified. If many never verify, sign up yourself from fresh addresses at a few providers and check the delivery time, the spam folder, and whether the email says what to do.
Can Mimiq tell me my signup rate?
No. A run shows where simulated newcomers get stuck, what breaks, and why. It does not predict how many real visitors will sign up. Your analytics give you the rate.
Will the visitors create accounts on my site?
Yes. They really submit your forms, so each visitor that gets through leaves a test account with a Mimiq email address. Delete them afterwards, or test on a staging copy.
What does a run cost?
Your first test is free with a free account: sign in with Google or email and it starts right away, no card. The account includes 50 credits, enough for 10 visitors. After that a visitor uses 5 credits, and then it is a $9 Starter (120 credits that never expire) or monthly plans from $19.
Keep reading
Send visitors and see what breaks first.
Your first test is free: sign in with Google or email and it starts right away. Last checked 2026-11-01.