By industry

Roof replacement website: why estimates stall

A homeowner saw a storm ad and wants a free look at the roof. Mimiq sends a simulated visitor through your estimate path and shows the field where they gave up.

5 visitors try to .
First test free with an accountRun it from your coding agent

Why does a roof replacement website get clicks but few estimate requests?

A roof replacement website gets clicks and few estimate requests when the form asks for measurements and insurance details a homeowner does not have yet. The homeowner who clicked a roof ad has a leak or storm damage and wants two answers: will someone come out, and does it cost anything. A simulated test sends a visitor from the same kind of ad through the estimate form and shows the first field that stopped them.

What this looks like in a report

Who
Kofi, whose kitchen ceiling is stained after the last storm
How they arrived
Clicked a paid ad that promised a free roof inspection after storms
Where they stopped
Estimate form, on the first required field

“The ad said free inspection. This form wants my square footage and my insurance company before it mentions a visit. I don't know either, so I'm leaving.”

The fix. Put the words free roof inspection in the first line of the form, and make square footage and the insurance company optional fields below the address. Add a line saying a person will confirm the measurements at the visit.

An illustration. Run a test to see your own.See a real sample report

The ad promised a free look, and the form asks for square footage first

A storm sends homeowners to search and to ads at the same time. Someone sees a stain on the ceiling, reads a line about a free roof inspection after hail, and taps through. The landing page repeats the promise in a large headline. The form below it then asks for the roof's square footage, the number of stories, the insurance carrier and a photo upload, before it says when anyone will call. A homeowner who does not know the square footage cannot finish, and will not guess a number that might matter for a claim.

  • Does the first screen repeat the exact offer from the ad, such as a free inspection?
  • Is the first required field one a homeowner can answer without a tape measure?
  • Can the form be finished without naming an insurance company?
  • After the photo step, does the page confirm the upload and say when someone calls?

The ad sets the promise, and the landing page has to keep it

A roof ad and a roof search bring two different homeowners. The searcher has a leak, a missing shingle or a neighbor who got hail damage. The paid click often has a headline about storms and an offer for a free inspection, and it expects the next screen to repeat that offer. When the first screen talks about craftsmanship and warranties instead, the visitor has to wonder whether the offer still applies, and many go back without filling in anything.

You cannot see the mismatch from inside, because the offer is familiar to you. Compare the ad you bought with the first screen of your page. Note whether the word that drew the click appears before the form starts. If it does not, the cause is the promise, and no form change will bring that visitor back. Read the ad aloud, then the first screen, and check that the promise carries over.

Square footage, insurance names and photo uploads a homeowner cannot finish

The estimate form is where storm visitors often stop. A homeowner can see a stained ceiling and a row of missing shingles, but not the roof area in square feet. If the first required field asks for that, the form has no answer for them. The second stop is the insurance carrier. A homeowner who is not sure whether a claim is open does not want to name a company in a web form, and a required field stops them.

The photo step fails quietly. Phone browsers handle uploads differently from laptops, and a page that does not confirm the file arrived leaves the homeowner unsure whether they sent anything. After an upload, the page should say what was received and when someone will call. Test that step with a photo from your own phone. Check that the confirmation reads clearly on a small screen, not only in a laptop window.

The storm estimate, and the first field a run cannot finish

Send one simulated visitor with this task: ask for a free estimate after hail damage on the roof. The visitor is a homeowner on a phone who has seen water on a ceiling and does not know the roof's measurements. Paste the ad text as the way the visitor arrives, so the report compares the promise with what your first screen delivers. Leave square footage out of the task.

The run follows the visitor from the ad to the first screen, then through the form and the photo step. It stops at a text code, a card payment or a Google sign-in, and the report names the step. A deposit or booking fee ends at the payment step. If the run stops on square footage, make that field optional, then run the same ad text again and check whether the photo step opens.

Ways to find why roof estimate requests stall

MethodShows youMisses
Form analyticsHow many visitors started the form and where they left itWhat the visitor expected when they arrived
Session replayThe clicks and scrolls of real visitors on a given pageVisitors who never reached the page
Simulated visitor runThe step and field where a visitor stopped, with a screenshotHow many real homeowners will request an estimate

Use the run and the replay to find the field. Use form analytics for the rate.

What you get with Mimiq

  1. 01

    Run it by hand, or on every pull request

    Paste a link and a task in the app and watch the visitors work. Or run them on every preview deploy: the GitHub Action comments on the pull request, any other CI can call the MCP endpoint, and your coding agent can run it too.

  2. 02

    Bugs and usability problems in one report

    The browser records errors and failed or slow requests on the step they happened. The visitors say where the wording or the steps confused them, and where they left.

  3. 03

    Visitors that behave like your audience

    Each visitor is a different profile with a reason to be there, matched to who the page is for, described by you, or built from your own customers.

  4. 04

    A prompt to fix each problem

    Every problem comes with a fix to paste into Cursor, Claude Code, Lovable or any coding agent, and one prompt hands over the top problems at once. Then send the same visitors through again.

  5. 05

    Follow every visitor

    See each visitor's whole path, step by step with screenshots, and what it was thinking at every step. Ask any visitor a question.

The browser records relevant JavaScript errors and failed or slow app requests encountered during the run, attached to the step where they occurred. The visitors are simulated: they find problems, they do not predict how many real people will convert.

A new storm campaign can send visitors to a form that asks for the insurer first

Storm seasons bring new ads, new landing pages and new forms, and each campaign can send a different promise to a form built for the old one. Rerun the same ad text after every change, and again when a new campaign starts. If the estimate form sits behind a login for returning customers, run a test account through it, and check each preview before it goes live.

Starter

Try it on one launch

$9 once
120 credits, never expire

About 4 tests of 5 visitors

  • Visitors on your landing page, signup and checkout
  • Where they left and why, with a fix to copy for each problem
  • Run it in the app or on every pull request
  • Ask any visitor a question, included
  • Test accounts and protected previews
Buy 120 credits

Builder

Test every build

$19 a month
500 credits every month

About 20 tests of 5 visitors

  • Everything in Starter
  • Credits refill each month, and what is left rolls over once
  • Cancel anytime
Choose Builder

Pro

Test every release, as a team

$49 a month
1,500 credits every month

About 60 tests of 5 visitors

  • Everything in Starter
  • Credits refill each month, and what is left rolls over once
  • Cancel anytime
Choose Pro

Scale

Test at scale, every day

$149 a month
6,000 credits every month

About 240 tests of 5 visitors

  • Everything in Starter
  • Credits refill each month, and what is left rolls over once
  • Priority support
  • Cancel anytime
Choose Scale
$0for your first test, with a free account (Google sign-in, no card). It includes 50 credits, enough for 10 visitors. After that a visitor uses 5 credits, and packs start at $9 for 120 credits.
See a sample report

Questions

Does this tell me how many estimates I will sell?

No. Mimiq does not predict how many estimates a page will bring in or how many become jobs. It shows the first field a simulated visitor could not finish, and what the page showed them. Rates come from your form analytics and your sales records.

Can the test confirm that insurance will cover the roof?

No. The run does not check insurance rules or claims, and it cannot tell a visitor what a claim will pay. Do not let the page promise coverage it cannot back. Have whoever handles claims review any insurance wording before it goes live.

Does the test prove a real roof photo reaches me?

Not as proof that a file arrived. The run shows whether the upload control appears on a phone and what the page says after that step. Send one real photo from your own phone to confirm the whole path, including the email the homeowner receives.

Should the form ask for the insurance company at all?

Not in the first step. Ask for it later, once the homeowner has an appointment, and label it optional on the first screen. A visitor who does not know the carrier should still reach a confirmation that someone will call.

Keep reading

Send visitors and see what breaks first.

Your first test is free: sign in with Google and it starts right away. Last checked 2026-11-02.

5 visitors try to .